ARL E-Directory: Updates & Comments Birdie MacLennan 04 Feb 1992 19:35 UTC
4 messages, 100 lines: ------------------------- Date: Mon, 27 Jan 1992 11:07:00 EST From: Bill Drew -- Serials Librarian <DREWWE@SNYMORVA.BITNET> Subject: Directory of Electronic Journal out of print!! Our library just recently placed an order for the Directory of Electronic Journals from ARL. We just received a letter DATED NOVEMBER 1991 that the print copy was out of stock. We placed our order in early January. I would like to know why ARL could not inform us via the listservers of this fact? The letter we received was dated November 1991. There certainly was enough publicity when it was first made available. Why not inform us when one format is no longer available? It costs us at least $5.00 to cut a check. THIS IS A FLAME MESSAGE. -Bill Drew- ****************************************************************** Wilfred Drew (call me "BILL") Serials/Reference/Computers Librarian SUNY College of Agriculture & Technology P.O. Box 902, Morrisville, NY 13408-0902 Bitnet: drewwe@snymorva SUNYNET(DECnet): smorv::drewwe InterNet: drewwe@SNYMORVA.CS.SNYMOR.EDU Voice: 315-684-6055 Fax: 315-684-6115 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Date: Mon, 03 Feb 92 10:15:16 EST From: Ann Lillian Okerson <OKERSON@UMDC> Subject: Response to Bill Drew In publishing the Directory of Electronic Journals, Newsletters & Academic Discussion Lists, we did not fully take into account the power of networked announcements in selling the directory, nor apparently of the interest there would be in such a directory. When we sold out in November, we faced the practical and philosophical question: do we reprint more paper copies when a new edition is projected in winter of 1991/2? Given our resources, we decided that our energies should be channelled to the new version rather than to selling the current one. I believe (though I cannot guarantee it) that we posted a network announcement saying the paper was sold out but that a diskette version would continue to be available until the new paper edition was in print. We also drafted the November letter which we use as a form letter for any orders we may receive in the interim. Most customers choose to purchase the diskette; some hold the checks for next month's new publication. Our next print run will be substantially larger, as the reviews that are starting to appear are generating a new round of orders. We will keep the publication in print into the fall of 1992. We plan that the Directory should be a serial. So far it is not very regular (1st edition: July 1991; 2nd, March 1992) because we are still trying to determine what is the optimum time between editions, and that means making a judgment about how much time elapses before there are enough changes and editions to bring out a new volume. The net is a moving target; it's early days for determ- mining just how fast it is moving. We hope that the printed Directory is a service to our customers and regret any inconveniences -- Ann Okerson/ARL ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Date: Thu, 30 Jan 1992 09:02 EST From: Bill Drew -- Serials Librarian <DREWWE@snymorva.bitnet> Subject: Re: ARL Directory of E-Journals I know my message about the ARL Directory was a little hot but we are in desperate budgetary constaints at the State University of New York. In fact, I have qualms about ordering the directory any way. I believe that it should be free of charge as a public service to the users of the INTERNET. I know that much of the material available in it is already here on the network but the formats need improvement. It is a matter of principle to me that ARL should have informed the same lists that the paper edition was out of print. They certainly kept us well informed about the arrival of the publication. You may add this to my other comments if you wish. -Bill Drew- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Date: Tues 4 Feb 1992 Subject: Network Alternatives Editor's Note: Network sources that cover material in the ARL Directory and that are (I presume) maintained, updated, and retrievable on an ongoing basis include: A directory of Bitnet and Internet conferences classified by subject & including descriptions. Broken down into six files. To retrieve, send a "get" command to: LISTSERV@KENTVM. GET ACADLIST FILE1 GET ACADLIST FILE2 GET ACADLIST FILE3 GET ACADLIST FILE4 GET ACADLIST FILE5 GET ACADLIST FILE6 Contact Diane Kovacs (LIBRK329@KENTVMS) for additional information. Also: A comprehensive listing of electronic serials is retrievable (in two files) by issuing "get" commands to: LISTSERV@UOTTAWA. Watch the spelling on these! GET EJOURNL1 DIRECTRY GET EJOURNL2 DIRECTRY Contact Michael Strangelove (441495@ACADVM1.UOTTAWA.CA) for more information.