Re: Electronic vs Print pricing comparison (Joanna Tousley-Escalante) Stephen Clark 24 Mar 1999 18:33 UTC
---------- Forwarded message ---------- Date: Wed, 24 Mar 1999 17:47:00 +0100 From: J.Tousley@iaea.org Subject: RE: Electronic vs Print pricing comparison (Jason Eyre) >>From our experience, I would confirm your views. Not so much available, and usually the cost is equal to print or greater than print for the electronic version. Just today I received email from an EBSCO representative in a related question we have with them, and she made this point: > 3. Prices: > Publishers mainly offer three options: > a) free online access with a paper subscription > b) paid online access in form of a surcharge on the print price in > combination with a paper subscriptions > c) paid online access independantly from a paper journal (rarely the case > yet) > Notice her qualifier under 3.c. It is a good guide to what is available and how to plot the costs for online versus print access. Regards, Joanna Tousley-Escalante * Head Technical Services Unit * Vienna International Centre Library * IAEA * Wagramer Str. 5, P.O. Box 100 * A-1400 Vienna, Austria * tel: *43-1/2600-22624 * fax: *43-1/2600-29584 * j.tousley@iaea.org > ---------- > From: Stephen Clark[SMTP:sdclar@janus.swem.wm.edu] > Sent: Wednesday, March 24, 1999 15:44 > To: SERIALST@LIST.UVM.EDU > Subject: Electronic vs Print pricing comparison (Jason Eyre) > > ---------- Forwarded message ---------- > Date: Wed, 24 Mar 1999 13:01:08 +1000 > From: Jason Eyre <Jason.Eyre@EPA.VIC.GOV.AU> > Subject: Electronic vs Print pricing comparison > > Dear colleagues > > The library for the Environment Protection Authority in Victoria, > Australia, is being encouraged to embrace electronic journals as a viable > - and cheaper - alternative to the more traditional print variety, as well > as being more environmentally-friendly (as less paper is used). > > While we are keen to do this (and, indeed have already done to a limited > but growing extent), our PERCEPTIONS are that the electronic journals > currently available are comparatively MORE EXPENSIVE (due primarily, but > not exclusively, to the licensing arrangements for multiple access > points). In addition, the RANGE of e-journals available is SIGNIFICANLY > LOWER compared to those on offer in a print format, particularly for a > specialist scientific/technical library such as ours. > > What I want to ask you all is this: Are our perceptions founded? Are > e-journals more expensive than print (in your own experience)? Can anyone > point me to a recent, authoritative analysis of this issue? What are the > relative advantages/disadvantages of electronic over print? Do any of you > have experiences/examples that you can relate on this matter? > > A rather broad-ranging question, I admit; but I am keen to hear your > opinions on at least some of these issues.... > > Regards > Jason Eyre > ------------------------------------------------- > Serials and Acquisitions Librarian > EPA Library > Environment Protection Authority > 477 Collins Street > GPO Box 4395QQ > Melbourne Victoria 3001 > Australia > -------------------------------------------------- >