Re: A chart that couples ISSNs? Eric Hellman 29 Feb 2008 14:47 UTC
check out the beta version of OCLC's xISSN service, which we previewed at ALA midwinter. http://xissn.worldcat.org/ Official launch coming RSN. Eric On Feb 8, 2008, at 11:47 AM, Michael wrote: > > The question: > Does anyone have an up-to-date chart that will couple a given > titles print ISSN to its electronic ISSN? > > Why Im asking: > We use a subscription agent and over the course of a year we > subscribe and cancel titles. We have an A-Z list provided by a > separate vendor. We have yet another vendor that supplies a > meaningful degree of archival access to many of these titles in > addition to the access that the publishers supply to the same > titles. And of course we have the publishers and/or their host sites. > > With that many parties involved in providing access to thousands of > titles it is easy to see how they can get out of sync with each > other. It makes good sense to periodically check to make sure every > thing that we pay for, in every form that we pay for it, is > operational. > > A way to check to see that everything is as it should be is to > download a list from each relevant vendor/provider/publisher and > compare them to each other. If I bought a title through subscription > agent A from publisher B, I want to see it in vendor Cs list. If I > compare the three lists from the 3 parties and all 3 say I have > access that title, chances are good that I actually do have access. > This is more efficient than going title by title through the OPAC > even if that is the most reliable way to do it. But Im open to a > discussion of better ways of verifying access to a long list of > titles. > > The problem is that subscription agent A is likely to say I have > access to Journal of the Boss Hogg Society and because it has an > electronic element, theyll use the e-ISSN. At the same time, > publisher B sells print plus with emphasis on print so they use the > print ISSN and they list the title as *The* journal of the Boss > Hogg society. And in the meantime, vendor C is into shorthand > titles so they list it as Jnl Boss Hogg Society and they > occasionally use the print ISSN for some titles and the e-ISSN for > other titles. > > I can run electronic list comparisons but only if I have a > consistent match point. The best way that we have come up with is a > chart where the different format ISSNs are linked together along > with a title. That way the title can vary enough to throw it off in > a list but still be matchable. Any ideas? I'm always open to ideas > on better ways of doing things. > > Thanks to all, > Michael Lampley > Serials Librarian > Texas Christian University > TCU Box 2984000 > 2913 West Lowden St. > Fort Worth, TX 76129 > 817 257 6485 TEL > m.lampley@tcu.edu > > > > _______________________________________________ > No banners. No pop-ups. No kidding. > Make My Way your home on the Web - http://www.myway.com Eric Hellman, Director OCLC New Jersey hellmane@oclc.org 2 Broad St., Suite 208 tel 1-973-509-7800 fax 1-734-468-6216 Bloomfield, NJ 07003 http://nj.oclc.org/